Racing NSW to mandate body bags and chain of custody after So You Are scandal

Racing NSW acting chief executive Graeme Hinton says draft rules requiring timely burial or cremation, body bags, and tracking of horses after death will go to participants, with implementation targeted by the end of November and a national rule change to be discussed at a Racing Australia board meeting.

Racing NSW is preparing new rules governing the handling, burial and cremation of deceased thoroughbreds following the discovery of So You Are’s remains in Sydney. (Photo by Bronwen Healy. The Image is Everything – Bronwen Healy Photography)

Racing NSW will require participants to place horses that die in a body bag, have them buried or cremated in a timely manner and record where their remains go, under draft rules drawn up after the remains of Melbourne Cup runner So You Are were found in a waste skip at Lucas Heights in southern Sydney.

Acting chief executive Graeme Hinton, whose appointment to the role becomes permanent on December 1, says that the regulator would consult the industry immediately and aims to have the rules in force within weeks.

“Our next step, which commences today, is we’ll take these draft rules and processes to our participants. We’ll consult on them very quickly with a view to having rules implemented by the end of the month that set those standards moving forward,” Hinton told SEN’s Giddy Up With Gareth Hall.

Hinton said Racing NSW had spent the previous 48 hours reviewing industry practices and its current rules, and that the new obligation would apply to every horse regardless of how it died.

“It will be quite simple in that you must ensure that every horse has a timely burial or cremation after its death, that it is provided with dignity and respect,” he said.

“We’re going to require the use of a body bag for a horse after it passes, and that’s about making sure that it is provided with that dignity and respect.

“And we’re also going to implement a chain of custody and a reporting mechanism to make sure we understand where they go after they’ve died,” he said.

The existing national rule on dead horses, AR 299, requires the trainer, manager or authorised agent to notify Racing Australia within 24 hours of the death of a named horse that has not been retired under AR 297, and bars disposal of the body without written approval from the principal racing authority unless a veterinary certificate stating the cause of death has been supplied.

Hinton said the failure in So You Are’s case lay in how the horse was handled, not where it was sent. NSW Department of Primary Industries guidelines prefer a licensed landfill for euthanised animals because of the chemicals involved.

“One of those recommendations is that a horse that has been euthanised, that has barbiturates in its bloodstream from that process, should be sent to a licensed landfill,” he said.

“And that is the process that the veterinary practice has undertaken, but where they’ve let us down and let the horse down is that they haven’t maintained a process of dignity and respect through that, and they’ve just allowed the horse to be abandoned there.

“What I’ve learnt from the consultation we’ve done over the last couple of days is some of our participants, not many, and I can also say some of our vets, have a view that once an animal has passed, it has passed.

“The level of dignity and respect that we would expect, and I certainly expect, isn’t necessarily uniform across the board. Our role as the regulator is to set that bar and say this is what we will and won’t accept.”

Hinton has spoken to Racing Queensland acting chief executive Lachlan Murray and Racing Victoria chief executive Aaron Morrison, and said the matter was on the agenda for a Racing Australia board meeting held on Thursday.

Under AR 9, Racing Australia alone can make or amend the Australian Rules of Racing, while principal racing authorities are limited to Local Rules.

“New South Wales, we’re leading the way because this has landed on our plate and we’re moving first, but I also have a lot of confidence that the other states and RAs at a national level will be quickly behind us as well to have something in place across the board,” he said.

“What happened this week shows you how very quickly the poor conduct of one or two people can impact all of us and how quickly that can escalate. So it’s going to take us months and potentially years to undo this damage. And we certainly don’t get a second chance at it. This is actually a global racing risk,” Hinton said.

Across the Tasman, New Zealand Thoroughbred Racing already funds transport and cremation after race and trial fatalities through its welfare levy where regional services exist.

Racing NSW has said it will take action if its continuing investigation finds wrongdoing.

Close the CTA

Read our newsletters today

Free access to our daily and feature newsletters, covering exclusive and premium content in racing, wagering and breeding, direct to your inbox