Triple theft joins long history of missing Melbourne Cups

The theft of Makybe Diva’s three Melbourne Cup trophies from Flemington follows trophy thefts dating back to the 1930s, while the whereabouts of Phar Lap’s 1930 Cup remain unresolved.

Melbourne Cup
Several Melbourne Cup trophies have gone missing in the past. (Photo by Scott Barbour/Racing Photos via Getty Images)

The theft of Makybe Diva’s three Melbourne Cups is the latest in a series of stolen and missing trophies going back more than eight decades.

Offenders allegedly wearing hi-vis clothing smashed a glass display case in the Hill Stand on Monday morning, taking the three trophies, which were valued at more than $1 million each.

The trophies belong to owner and breeder Tony Santic and were on loan to the Victoria Racing Club (VRC) for an exhibition.

Trivalve’s 1927 Melbourne Cup was stolen from a glass display case at Melbourne’s Athenaeum Club in January 1938. A contemporary report in the Otago Daily Times described the trophy as 18-carat gold and said a thief was believed to have smashed the case with a heavy cigarette tray.

Artilleryman’s Melbourne Cup was stolen from the Melbourne Club in May 1939. According to historical writer Pauline Conolly’s account, detectives recovered it at a Clifton Hill house two months later, with the bowl broken from the stem.

On October 22, 1963, the trophy intended for that year’s winning owner disappeared from the window of the New Zealand Government Tourist Bureau, at the corner of Elizabeth and Collins streets.

Police believed three men had worked together, two keeping staff busy while the third took the gold-plated cup, which was officially valued at £750.

“The cup, which we have had on display since September 20, was sitting in the window under the eye of a receptionist,” bureau manager T. G. Robinson told The Age at the time. He had believed the trophy was a replica.

The race went ahead with a trophy because the VRC commissioned two cups each year in case of a dead-heat or damage. Club chairman Ross Grey Smith said at the time that making a suitable trophy took three to six months and that, as far as he knew, only one man in Victoria could do the work.

In 2010, police said a Melbourne Cup trophy reported stolen in a burglary had been found inside its owner’s Ascot Vale home. It was the 18-carat gold trainer’s trophy awarded to Robert Sinclair for Wodalla’s 1953 win.

Strapper Stevie Payne’s trophy was stolen while he celebrated at a Ballarat pub after Prince Of Penzance’s 2015 win under his sister, Michelle Payne. Actor and director Rachel Griffiths presented him with a replacement at Flemington in 2018. The original had not been returned by then.

In October 2019, burglars ransacked Houdini’s Cafe e Cucina at Diggers Rest. They took the cash register, cash and part-owner Mark Ruff’s replica of Rekindling’s 2017 Cup, which had been on display there for about two years.

Phar Lap’s 1930 Cup is still unaccounted for. In 2005, a trophy that New South Wales car dealer Bob Todd had received as part-payment for a car was put forward as the missing Cup. The VRC ruled it out after its experts compared it with the original records. Goldsmith James Steeth’s logbook put the original at 35 troy ounces, nearly 1.1kg, while Todd’s weighed 915 grams.

Racing historian Andrew Lemon said in 2010 that he believed Phar Lap’s trainer and part-owner, Harry Telford, may have sold the Cup back to the supplier, after which it was polished, re-engraved and presented for Wodalla’s 1953 win.

It was then bought from Wodalla’s owner’s estate and given to Beldale Ball’s connections in 1980. The VRC still describes the identification as unproven.

“I can’t say with 100 per cent certainty that it’s Phar Lap’s, but on the evidence we have, that’s my belief,” Lemon told The Age in 2010. “I would still love someone to walk into my office with documents proving it, but it seems that one Cup has been won three times.”

Close the CTA

Read our newsletters today

Free access to our daily and feature newsletters, covering exclusive and premium content in racing, wagering and breeding, direct to your inbox